Beef nihari is a slow-cooked Pakistani stew of beef shank in a spiced, lightly thickened gravy. The meat should yield to a spoon while the sauce stays loose enough to scoop with naan. Getting both textures right takes two separate decisions: cook the shank until tender, then thicken the liquid. Fresh ginger, lemon, and sliced green chile go on at the table, where their sharpness cuts through the rich gravy.

The short answer
Cook 2½ lb (1.13 kg) boneless beef shank with optional marrow bones, homemade nihari masala, and water at a covered, gentle simmer for 3½ to 5 hours, checking tenderness rather than the clock. Lift out the tender meat, whisk in an atta-and-cold-water slurry, and simmer the gravy for 20 to 25 minutes. Return the beef and finish with ginger, cilantro, green chile, and lemon.
Jump to
What makes beef nihari different from other beef stews?
Nihari combines slow-cooked shank, a fragrant spice blend, and flour-thickened gravy. Fennel and dried ginger give the masala a character different from an everyday curry powder. The finished sauce surrounds large pieces of meat rather than a mix of potatoes and vegetables.
Pakistani recipes vary in their spices, onions, and finishing fat. Sarah Mir’s nihari, for example, uses homemade masala and a late atta slurry. This version follows that broad approach, with measured salt and a separate gravy-finishing stage. For another spiced, slow-cooked dish, our lamb rogan josh takes a different route to tender meat.
Which beef shank should you buy for nihari?
Buy boneless beef shank in large chunks, with marrow bones on the side if available. Ask for 2½ lb (1.13 kg) of trimmed meat cut into roughly 2½-inch pieces. Add 1 lb (450 g) of beef marrow bones for a richer pot; their weight is separate from the meat.
Shank has connective tissue that softens during a long, moist cook and contributes gelatin to the liquid. Do not trim away every pale seam running through the meat. Remove hard exterior fat and any loose bone fragments, but keep the connective tissue that gives this cut its purpose.
Cross-cut, bone-in shanks work too, but a 2½ lb package contains less edible meat. Ask the butcher for enough to supply about 2½ lb of meat after accounting for bone. Chuck is a workable substitute in the same boneless weight; start checking it sooner because tenderness depends on both the cut and chunk size.

Ingredients for beef nihari and homemade nihari masala
You need beef shank, ginger, garlic, a fennel-forward masala, and atta for the gravy. Water lets the spices and beef lead; salty stock makes the final seasoning harder to control. The homemade blend below makes one batch, with no packet seasoning needed.
For the stew
- 2½ lb (1.13 kg) boneless beef shank, cut into 2½-inch chunks
- 1 lb (450 g) beef marrow bones, optional
- ⅓ cup (80 ml) ghee or neutral oil
- 1 medium yellow onion, thinly sliced
- 1½ tbsp finely grated fresh ginger
- 1½ tbsp finely grated garlic
- 8 cups (1.9 liters) water, plus hot water as needed
- 10 g kosher salt to start, about 3½ tsp Diamond Crystal or 2 tsp Morton, plus more to taste
For the nihari masala, use all of it
- 1 tbsp fennel seeds
- 1 tbsp coriander seeds
- 2 tsp cumin seeds
- 1 tsp black peppercorns
- 4 whole cloves
- 4 green cardamom pods, seeds removed and shells discarded
- 1 black cardamom pod, seeds removed and shell discarded
- 1-inch cinnamon stick, broken into small pieces
- 2 tsp Kashmiri chile powder
- 1 tsp ground dried ginger
- ½ tsp ground turmeric
- ¼ tsp ground nutmeg
- ⅛ tsp ground mace
- ¼ tsp cayenne, optional, for more heat
To thicken and serve
- ⅓ cup (40 g) atta, finely milled whole-wheat flour
- 1 cup (240 ml) cold water
- 2 tbsp fresh ginger, cut into thin matchsticks
- ¼ cup chopped cilantro
- 1 to 2 green chiles, thinly sliced
- 1 lemon, cut into wedges
- Warm naan or roti, for serving
Equipment: a 6- to 7-quart heavy pot with a snug lid, a spice grinder, tongs, a whisk, and a ladle. A heavy base matters most after the flour goes in, when the gravy can catch underneath the meat.
How to slow-cook beef nihari on the stovetop
Cook the beef gently until tender before adding the flour slurry. Allow a generous afternoon: the covered simmer alone may take 3½ to 5 hours. Keep the burner low enough that the liquid bubbles lazily rather than tossing the meat around.
- Toast and grind the masala. Put the fennel, coriander, cumin, peppercorns, cloves, cardamom seeds, and cinnamon in a dry skillet over medium-low heat. Stir for 1 to 2 minutes, until fragrant, without darkening them heavily. Cool, grind finely, and mix with the remaining ground spices.
- Cook the onion. Heat the ghee in the heavy pot over medium heat. Add the onion and cook for 10 to 12 minutes, stirring, until golden. Lower the heat if the edges darken before the centers soften.
- Add the beef and aromatics. Pat the meat dry, add it to the pot, and turn it in the fat for 5 to 7 minutes, until its exterior changes color and lightly browns in places. Add the fresh ginger and garlic and cook for 1 minute. This is a brief fry, not a steak-style crust.
- Bloom the spices. Reduce the heat to low. Stir in all the masala for about 30 seconds, adding a splash of the measured water if it starts sticking. Immediately add the remaining 8 cups of water, the salt, and the optional bones. Scrape the base clean.
- Cover and simmer. Bring just to a boil, then reduce to a gentle simmer and cover. Cook for 3½ to 5 hours. Check liquid and sticking every 45 to 60 minutes, turning pieces gently. Add hot water as needed to keep the beef mostly submerged.
- Check individual pieces. Begin testing at 3 hours. A fork should enter easily and twist a small portion away without a rubbery tug. Lift ready pieces onto a plate while firmer pieces continue cooking. Remove bones and check the pot for fragments.
- Thicken the gravy. With the meat out, whisk the atta into 1 cup cold water until smooth. Whisk the slurry again immediately before pouring it slowly into the gently simmering gravy. Cook uncovered for 20 to 25 minutes, stirring along the bottom frequently.
- Return and finish. Add hot water in ¼-cup increments if the gravy becomes too thick. Return the beef and its juices, warm gently for about 5 minutes, and taste for salt. Rest off the heat for 10 minutes, then serve with the fresh garnishes and naan.
Watch Food Fusion make beef nihari
Food Fusion demonstrates beef nihari with a homemade masala and a flour liaison. Its pressure-cooker method and separate chile-oil finish differ from this covered stovetop version; follow the quantities and timing above for this recipe.
If the video does not load, watch it on YouTube.
How to thicken nihari without lumps or broken meat
Remove the tender beef, thicken the liquid separately, then return the meat. That gives you room to whisk and scrape the base without shredding the pieces you spent hours cooking. It also lets unevenly sized chunks finish at their own pace.
Before adding flour, look at the liquid. If evaporation has left very little gravy, restore it with hot water first. If the beef is swimming in excess liquid, reduce that liquid before thickening. Flour should give a properly concentrated broth a light coating texture, not rescue a watery pot with more and more starch.
What should the finished gravy look like?
The gravy should lightly coat a spoon and still pour freely. Judge it while hot: gelatin and flour both make it thicker as it cools. A spoonful should spread in the bowl rather than hold a mound, and a little surface fat is expected.
How do you fix lumps or a floury taste?
Strain lumpy gravy while the meat is out; simmer floury gravy longer. Press the liquid through a fine sieve, return it to the pot, and continue cooking gently. Do not add dry flour directly to the pot, and do not stop cooking as soon as the first thickening appears.
What to serve with nihari
Serve nihari with warm naan or roti and a small plate of ginger, cilantro, green chile, and lemon. Add the garnishes to individual bowls so each person controls the heat and acidity. Start with a small squeeze of lemon, taste, and add more.
Plain basmati rice also works if bread is unavailable. Keep any cucumber salad or yogurt alongside rather than stirring it into the shared pot. The stew is already the main event; it does not need another rich curry next to it.
Make-ahead, storage, and reheating
Make nihari a day ahead, chill it promptly, and loosen the gravy as it reheats. Keep the fresh garnishes separate. The chilled stew may set firmly from gelatin; that does not mean you added too much atta.
Follow USDA leftover guidance: divide the stew into shallow containers and refrigerate within 2 hours, or 1 hour when the surrounding temperature is above 90°F (32°C). Keep the refrigerator at 40°F (4°C) or below and use the stew within 3 to 4 days. Do not leave the covered cooking pot on the counter overnight.
Freeze meal-size portions for longer storage and thaw in the refrigerator. Reheat with a splash of water, stirring carefully to prevent scorching. Under the USDA reheating recommendations, leftovers should reach 165°F (74°C), and gravy should come to a rolling boil. Check the center of a large beef piece as well as the surrounding sauce.
Questions about beef nihari
The most useful adjustments concern the beef, spice mix, and flour. Keep the same sequence of tenderizing the meat first and finishing the gravy afterward.
Can I use store-bought nihari masala?
Yes, replace the entire homemade blend with a packet mix measured for your meat weight. Follow its label and hold back the added salt until you taste the gravy, since many blends already contain salt. Do not add a full packet on top of the homemade masala.
Can I use all-purpose flour instead of atta?
Yes, start with ¼ cup (30 g) all-purpose flour mixed with the same cup of cold water. Its flavor and thickening differ from atta, so assess the hot gravy after simmering. If more body is needed, add a small additional cold-water slurry and cook it thoroughly.
Why is my beef still tough after four hours?
It usually needs more gentle cooking, provided there is enough liquid. Check that the pot is actually simmering, cover it again, and test every 30 minutes. A clock cannot account for every shank’s size and connective tissue.
Does nihari need an overnight cook?
No, this stovetop version cooks during the day and is ready when the shank becomes tender. An overnight schedule is not required for the texture. For next-day serving, finish the cook and refrigerate promptly rather than leaving it on an unattended burner.
Cook next on Meat Recipes Box
Beef Nihari: Pakistani Slow-Cooked Shank Stew
Did You Try Our Recipe ?
Chicken hears and gizzards
I would love you to send me the recipe please. I have no printer to print it off. [email protected]
Response from MeatRecipesBox
Hi Sharon, thank you so much for your kind words! I’ve just sent the full recipe to your inbox. Enjoy, and let me know how it turns out! 😊
Scrumptious
My husband (who is extremely picky) loved the liver & onions so much!! I didn’t have any beef broth or Sherry so I used about a tbl of Worcestershire and 1/4 c of white wine …..it was scrumptious
Response from MeatRecipesBox
Oh wow, I’m so happy to hear that!! 😍 I love that you made it work with what you had on hand — Worcestershire and white wine sound like a delicious twist. So glad your husband enjoyed it, especially being picky! Thank you for sharing your version, it makes me smile knowing it turned out scrumptious!
This was amazing
This recipe turned out really amazing! It’s juicy and spiced deliciously. I definitely would use less of the spicy pepper next time, but it really was delicious and I don’t think I’ll make chicken legs any other way from now on.!
Response from MeatRecipesBox
Thank you for taking the time to leave such a thoughtful review. I’m really glad to hear the recipe turned out juicy and full of flavor for you. That’s exactly what I was hoping for when putting it together. Good call on the spicy pepper as well. Adjusting the heat level to your own taste is always the best approach, and using a little less next time should make it just right for you. I really appreciate you trying the recipe and sharing your experience. It’s great to know it worked so well for you.
I Didn’t Expect This Cornbeef Hash Recipe to Taste This Good!!
One skillet. A handful of simple ingredients. Thirty minutes on the clock. And somehow… I ended up with the crispiest, most comforting cornbeef hash recipe I’ve made in years.
I wasn’t expecting much—just a quick, no-fuss meal. But that first bite? Crispy edges, tender potatoes, smoky corned beef, a little kick of pepper. It tasted like something straight off a cozy diner griddle.
Honestly, it caught me off guard—in the best way. Here’s why this simple skillet completely won me over.




